Want no ads? View Plans
Want no ads? View Plans
Appalachia 2023

Appalachia Christmas Cookie Sale


Our Appalachia Team is having our annual Christmas cookie sale December 17th and 18th!

A few things to keep in mind when choosing recipes:

  • Make as many dozens as you like! But we need a VARIETY of cookies, so be mindful of how many dozen you are making of any one particular recipe. We need to have a nice array of cookies on our plates.
  • Exception: if it's a well-loved recipe, like buckeyes or chocolate chip, you can make more.
  • Do not choose recipes that have cream in them.
  • Recipes that are gluten-free, please label them as such.
  • Please use throw-away containers or foil pans when dropping off. Your pans or tupperware will not be returned to you.

Here's the schedule:

Saturday, December 17th

12:00pm-1:00pm - Drop off cookies to the Cafeteria (use the door up the stairs from the outside gym doors). DO NOT BRING COOKIES AFTER 1:00PM! We need to start traying cookies at precisely 1:00. If you need to make arrangements to drop off your cookies earlier, please contact Cathy White at [email protected] or by cell at 412-973-8184.

1:00-2:00pm - Traying the cookies onto plates. This will begin immediately at 1:00pm.

Saturday and Sunday, December 17 and 18

At all weekend Masses, the cookie tables will be stocked and ready for selling before and after each Mass in the various church entrances. If you sign up to sell at a Mass, please specify under the comment section which entrance you will sell at (Breezeway, Narthex, or Baptismal) Find Cathy White and check in with her (she will be in the Breezeway).

Happy Baking! 

Created by:   Karen McElhaney
Already signed up? You can change your sign up.

Available Slot

What kind of cookie and how many dozen? (244)

All slots filled
Kevin Varley (30)
30 dozen (20 Holiday Chip and 10 Peanut Butter Blossom
marlene kish (15)
Gluten free and Chocolate Chip
Christie Kulbieda (10)
Fudge(6) and decorated Christmas cutout sugar cookies(4)
Connie Cortese (20)
We will have 30 dozen fudge and sugar cookies
Kerry Mindach (20)
Chocolate dipped macaroons & candied macaroons
Kristen Weiss (10)
Ginger snaps
Cathy White (30)
30 doz -white choc cranberry and m&m
Shari Hill (20)
GF no-bake, oatmeal choc chip, pb fudge & butter pecan/heath
Rita Caldwell (10)
Chocolate Chip & no bake cookies
Jeanne Zych
10 dozen thumb prints, 10 dozen health bar cookies, 10 dozen chocolate covered pretzels
Pam (Spencer/Jack) Miller (20)
(10) Ginger Snaps (10) Sugar
Mary Anne Detweiler (10)
Russian tea cakes and lemon lavender shortbread cookies - 10 dozen total
Carrie Sarraino (12)
6 doz Snickerdoodle, 6 doz Peanut Butter
Jennifer O'Rourke (10)
Jennifer Cramer (6)
Christmas play dough cookie (like sugar)
Joe Murray (30)
Chocolate chip, Mexican wedding balls and oatmeal raisin
Rick Metzger (9)
Ginger Snap and Chocolate Chip
Susan Young (10)
sugar, buckeyes, maybe something else

Plating cookies in cafeteria on Saturday, December 17 from 1:00-2:00pm (20)

All slots filled
Kevin Varley (3)
Jill, Jenna and Kevin
marlene kish
Christie Kulbieda (4)
Dan, Christie, Abbey, Riley
Connie Cortese
Kristen Weiss
Kristen weiss
Cathy White (2)
Russ and Cathy
Shari Hill (3)
3 Hills
Jeanne Zych
Carrie Sarraino
Elizabeth Sarraino
Jennifer Cramer (2)
Jen and Lily
Matthew Hill
One of the Hill’s

(STM) Selling Cookies at 4pm mass on Saturday, December 17 at 3:45-5:15pm (12)

All slots filled
Kevin Varley (3)
Jill, Jenna and Kevin
Christie Kulbieda (4)
Dan, Christie, Abbey, Riley
Jeanne Zych
Lynne Lindley
Happy to help set-up and sell
Laura Miller (3)
Ian/Julia + parent

(STM) Selling cookies at 8am Mass on Sunday, December 18 at 7:45am - 9:15am (12)

5 of 12 slots filled
Shari Hill (4)
Can work 2 stations
Jeanne Zych

(STM) Selling cookies at 9:30am Mass on Sunday, December 18 at 9:15am - 10:45am (12)

5 of 12 slots filled
Kerry Mindach (2)
Kerry & Tanner
Jeanne Zych
Connie Cortese (2)
Two from Cortese family will sell

(STM) Selling cookies at 11:30am Mass on Sunday, December 18 at 11:15am - 12:45pm (12)

8 of 12 slots filled
Kristen Weiss
Kristen weiss
Rita Caldwell (2)
Robert& Lisa
Jeanne Zych
Jennifer O'Rourke (3)
Sean, Jen and Meg
Rick Metzger
Erika Metzger

(SJC) Selling cookies at 5:00pm on Saturday, 4:45-6:15pm (6)

2 of 6 slots filled
marlene kish
Susan Young
Susan & Raina

(SJC) Selling cookies at 9am Mass on Sunday, December 18 at 8:45am - 10:15am (6)

3 of 6 slots filled
marlene kish
Peppy Pollock (2)
Matt and Peppy Pollock

(SJC) Selling cookies at 11am Mass on Sunday, December 18 at 10:45am - 12:15am (6)

5 of 6 slots filled
marlene kish
Peppy Pollock (2)
Matt and Peppy Pollock
Janet Devlin (2)
Janet and Chris
Want no ads? View Plans
Want no ads? View Plans
©2022 SignUpGenius.
All Rights Reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Service  |